Difference between revisions of "Writing Schwa"

From Mi'gmaq Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(25 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
In addition to the five main vowels ''a, e, i, o'' and ''u'', Mi'gmaq has an additional "sixth vowel". Written in the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ipa| International Phonetic Alphabet], it is [ə]. When written in the Listuguj [[Spelling| orthography]], it is written with an apostrophe. However, regardless of the spelling system used, it is for the most part not written. This page describes the places where schwa is written and where it is not.
+
In addition to the five main vowels ''a, e, i, o'' and ''u'', Mi'gmaq has an additional "sixth vowel", or [[schwa]]. Written in the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ipa| International Phonetic Alphabet], it is [ə]. When written in the Listuguj [[Spelling| orthography]], it is written with an apostrophe. However, regardless of the spelling system used, it is for the most part not written. This page describes the places where schwa is written and where it is not.
  
 
=Where to Write Schwa=
 
=Where to Write Schwa=
  
Schwa is written in any place where it is ''not predictable by rule''. That is, it is written when it is pronounced where it is not otherwise predicted by the writing system. The following section will detail the places where schwa is predictable and therefore ''not written''.
+
Schwa is written in any place where it is ''not predictable by rule''. That is, it is written when it is said and not predicted by the writing system. The following section will detail the places where schwa is predictable and therefore ''not written''.
  
 
=Where NOT to Write Schwa=
 
=Where NOT to Write Schwa=
  
These are all the places where schwa is predictable and ''not'' included in the orthography. They are broken up by word-initial, word-medial, and word-final '''epenthesis''' or insertion rules.
+
These are all the places where schwa is predictable and ''not'' included in the orthography. They are broken up by word-initial, word-medial, and word-final '''epenthesis''' or insertion rules. As a general rule of thumb, a schwa is inserted wherever a sequence of consonants cannot be [[Syllables|syllabified]] in Mi'gmaq.
  
 
==Word-Initial==
 
==Word-Initial==
Line 17: Line 17:
 
In this case, the "most sonorous" consonant is the consonant that is the loudest, or pronounced closest to the way a vowel is pronounced [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonority_hierarchy]. In Mi'gmaq, the hierarchy is as follows:
 
In this case, the "most sonorous" consonant is the consonant that is the loudest, or pronounced closest to the way a vowel is pronounced [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonority_hierarchy]. In Mi'gmaq, the hierarchy is as follows:
  
  vowels > ''l'' > ''n'' > ''m'' > ''s, p, t, g, q, gw, qw'', and possibly ''j'' as well
+
  all vowels > ''l'' > ''n'' > ''m'' > ''s, p, t, g, q, gw, qw'', and ''j''
  
Some examples of where to insert schwa are given in the table below (syllables marked off by dots):
+
Some examples of where to insert schwa are given in the table below. [[Syllables]] are marked off with dots. All audio examples are taken from the [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/ Mi'gmaq Talking Dictionary].
  
 
{| class="wikitable"
 
{| class="wikitable"
|+
+
|+ Schwa before ''m'', ''n'', ''l''
 
! Word||Pronunciation||Translation
 
! Word||Pronunciation||Translation
 
|-
 
|-
| lnui'sit
+
| '''ln'''ui'sit
| əl.nu.iː.sɪt
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/l/lnui%27sit/recording1.mp3 ['''əlː.n'''u.iː.sitʰ]]
 
| 'he speaks the native language'
 
| 'he speaks the native language'
 
|-
 
|-
| lmu'j
+
| '''lm'''u'j
| əl.muːtʃ
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/l/lmu%27j/recording1.mp3 ['''əl.m'''uːtʃ]]
 
| 'dog'
 
| 'dog'
 
|-
 
|-
| mlagejg
+
| '''ml'''agejg
| mə.la.gɛtʃk
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/m/mlagejg/recording1.mp3 ['''mə.l'''a.gɛtʃkʰ]]
 
| 'milk'
 
| 'milk'
 
|-
 
|-
| nmu'j
+
| '''nm'''u'j
| ən.muːtʃ
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/n/nmu%27j/recording1.mp3 ['''ən.m'''uːtʃ]]
 
| 'dog' (alternate pronunciation)
 
| 'dog' (alternate pronunciation)
 
|-
 
|-
| mntn
+
| '''mn'''tn
| mən.dən
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/m/mntn/recording1.mp3 ['''mən'''ː.dən]]
 
| 'mountain'
 
| 'mountain'
 
|-
 
|-
| smtug
+
| '''sm'''tug
| səm.tʊk
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/s/smtug/recording1.mp3 ['''səm̩̊'''ː.tukʷʰ]]
 
| 'right away'
 
| 'right away'
 
|-
 
|-
| slaps
+
| '''sl'''aps
| sə.laps
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/s/slaps/recording1.mp3 ['''sə.l'''aps]]
 
| 'slab of wood'
 
| 'slab of wood'
 
|-
 
|-
| snawei
+
| '''sn'''awei
| sə.na.wej
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/s/snawei/recording1.mp3 ['''sə.n'''a.wej]]
 
| 'maple tree'
 
| 'maple tree'
 
|}
 
|}
  
When the two consonants have the same sonority, however, the schwa is always placed before the first consonant. The following are some examples:
+
When the two consonants have the ''same sonority'', however, the schwa is always placed before the ''first'' consonant. The following are some examples:
  
 
{| class="wikitable"
 
{| class="wikitable"
|+
+
|+ Schwa before Consonants of the Same Sonority
 
! Word||Pronunciation||Translation
 
! Word||Pronunciation||Translation
 
|-
 
|-
| sgu'l
+
| '''sg'''u'l
| əs.kuːl
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/s/sgu%27l/recording1.mp3 ['''əsː.k'''uːl]]
 
| 'school'
 
| 'school'
 
|-
 
|-
| stoqon
+
| '''st'''oqon
| əs.to.ɢon
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/s/stoqon/recording1.mp3 ['''əsː.t'''ɔ.hon]]
 
| 'fir tree'
 
| 'fir tree'
 
|-
 
|-
| lluigneg
+
| '''ll'''uigneg
| əl.lu.i.gə.nɛk
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/l/lluigneg/recording1.mp3 ['''əl.l'''u.i.gə.nɛkʰ]]
 
| 'seven'
 
| 'seven'
 
|-
 
|-
| tgnu
+
| '''tg'''nu
| ət..nu
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/t/tgnu/recording1.mp3 ['''ətʰ.k'''ə.nu]]
 
| 'sweat'
 
| 'sweat'
 
|-
 
|-
| tqoq
+
| '''tq'''oq
| ət.qoq
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/t/tqoq/recording1.mp3 ['''ətʰ.ʕ'''ɔq͡χ]]
 
| 'last fall'
 
| 'last fall'
 
|-
 
|-
| ptaqan
+
| '''pt'''aqan
| əp.ta.ɢan
+
| ['''əp.t'''a.ħan]
 
| 'plate'
 
| 'plate'
 
|-
 
|-
| tplutaqan
+
| '''tp'''lutaqan
| ət..lu.da.ɢan
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/t/tplutaqan/recording1.mp3 ['''ət.p'''ə.lu.da.ħan]]
 
| 'law'
 
| 'law'
 
|-
 
|-
| gsnqo'qon
+
| '''gs'''nqo'qon
| ək.sən.qoː.ɢon
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/g/gsnqo%27qon/recording1.mp3 ['''ək.s'''ənˑ.hoː.hwɔn]]
 
| 'foolishness'
 
| 'foolishness'
 
|}
 
|}
Line 99: Line 99:
 
==Word-Medial==
 
==Word-Medial==
  
When ''two'' consonants appear between two vowels within a word (and are ''not identical'' consonants), the epenthesis rules are slightly different. Usually, the schwa appears between the consonants. However, this will only happen if the first consonant is ''lower in sonority'' than the second. In other words:
+
When ''two'' consonants appear between two vowels within a word (and are ''not identical'' consonants, or a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geminate geminate] consonant), the epenthesis rules are slightly different. Usually, the schwa appears between the consonants. However, this will only happen if the first consonant is ''lower in sonority'' than the second. In other words:
  
 
  "When two non-identical consonants are between two vowels, insert a schwa ''only'' if the first consonant is ''less sonorous'' than the second.  
 
  "When two non-identical consonants are between two vowels, insert a schwa ''only'' if the first consonant is ''less sonorous'' than the second.  
 
  Otherwise, insert no schwa."
 
  Otherwise, insert no schwa."
  
So, for example, a schwa will be inserted between ''q'' and ''n'' in the word ''oqnisgwa'tu'', 'cover it up', so that it is pronounced [o.ɢə.nis.gʷaː.du]. However, no schwa is necessary between the ''s'' and the ''gw'' in this word since ''s'' is higher in sonority than ''gw''. No schwa is needed in the word ''jiptug'', 'perhaps', as well, since both consonants are of the same sonority.
+
So, for example, a schwa will be inserted between ''q'' and ''n'' in the word ''o'''qn'''isgwa'tu'', 'cover it up', so that it is pronounced [o.'''ħə.n'''is.gwaː.du]. However, no schwa is necessary between the ''s'' and the ''gw'' in this word since ''s'' is of the same sonority as ''gw''. No schwa is needed in the word ''jiptug'', 'perhaps', as well, since both consonants are of the same sonority.
  
Note: This rule does not work as well with respect to the sound ''g'', which is subject to the epenthesis rules for some speakers and not for others. For example, some speakers will pronounce ''Mi'gmaq'' [miːk.maq] and others will pronounce it [miː..maq].
+
Note, however, that the consonants ''l'', ''m'', and ''n'' count as the '''same''' sonority in this case - there is no schwa inserted between the ''m'' and the ''l'' in [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/g/gamlamit/recording1.mp3 ''ga'''ml'''amit''], 'he or she breathes', because they count as the same.
  
When ''three or more'' consonants appear between two vowels (or word-initially), the schwa is generally inserted ''before the most sonorous'', as in the word-initial cases listed above. Two examples are given below:
+
When ''three or more'' consonants appear between two vowels (or word-initially), the schwa is generally inserted ''before the most sonorous'', as in the word-initial cases listed above. Three examples are given below:
  
 
{| class="wikitable"
 
{| class="wikitable"
|+
+
|+ Schwa Insertion with Three Consonants
 
! Word||Pronunciation||Translation
 
! Word||Pronunciation||Translation
 
|-
 
|-
| tplutaqan
+
| '''tpl'''utaqan
| ət.pə.lu.da.ɢan
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/t/tplutaqan/recording1.mp3 ['''ət.pə.l'''u.da.ħan]]
 
| 'law'
 
| 'law'
 
|-
 
|-
| o'plteg
+
| o''''plt'''eg
| oː.bəl.dɛk
+
| [oː.'''bəl.d'''ɛkʰ]
 
| 'it's not set right'
 
| 'it's not set right'
 
|-
 
|-
| gmsnmuaw
+
| '''gmsnm'''uaw
| gəm.sən.mu.aw
+
| ['''kəm.sən.m'''u.aw]
 
| 'do not take (imperative)'
 
| 'do not take (imperative)'
 
|}
 
|}
  
In ''o'plteg'', some speakers may simply replace the vowel with the ''l'' and pronounce it [oː.bl̩.dɛk]. This is very common word-finally, as in ''istua'latl'', 'he or she turns him or her sideways', pronounced [ɪs.du.aː.la.tl̩].
+
In ''o'plteg'', some speakers may simply replace the vowel with the ''l'' and pronounce it [oː.bl̩.dɛk]. This is very common word-finally, as in ''istua'latl'', 'he or she turns him or her sideways', pronounced [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/i/istua%27latl/recording1.mp3 [isˑ.du.aː.la.'''tl̩''']].
  
For words that have many consonants in a row, it is best to pick out the most sonorous and insert a schwa before it. So, if a form like ''gsnqo'qon'', 'foolishness', is encountered, a schwa will be inserted first before the ''n'', giving the provisionary [k.sən.qoː.qon]. No schwa needs to be inserted between the ''n'' and the ''q'', since ''n'' is higher in sonority than ''q''. A further schwa is needed to break up the ''gs'', however, so by the word-initial rules, it is inserted before the ''g'', giving the final [ək.sən.qoː.qon].
+
For words that have ''many consonants'' in a row, it is best to pick out the ''most sonorous'' and insert a schwa before it. So, if a form like '''''gsn'''qo'qon'', 'foolishness', is encountered, a schwa will be inserted first before the ''n'', giving the provisionary [ksən.qoː.qon]. No schwa needs to be inserted between the ''n'' and the ''q'', since ''n'' is higher in sonority than ''q''. A further schwa is needed to break up the ''gs'', however, so by the word-initial rules, it is inserted before the ''g'', giving the final [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/g/gsnqo%27qon/recording1.mp3 ['''ək.sən.h'''oː.hwon]].
  
If there is a ''double consonant'', however, the schwa will appear ''after the doubled consonant'', as in ''ennmtesg'', 'it pierces', pronounced [ɛn.nəm.tɛsk].
+
If there is a ''double consonant'' or '''geminate''', however, the schwa will appear ''after the geminate'', as in ''ennmtesg'', 'it pierces', pronounced [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/e/ennmtesg/recording1.mp3 ['''ɛn.nəm'''.tɛskʰ]]. This is occasionally written with the apostrophe in the Listuguj orthography and occasionally not.
  
 
==Word-Final==
 
==Word-Final==
  
When two consonants are located at the end of a word, a schwa is only inserted if the second consonant is ''more sonorous'' than the first consonant. Some examples are given below:
+
When two consonants are located at the end of a word, a schwa is only inserted if the second consonant is ''more sonorous'' than the first consonant.Some examples are given below:
  
 
{| class="wikitable"
 
{| class="wikitable"
|+
+
|+ Word-Final Schwa Insertion
 
! Word||Pronunciation||Translation
 
! Word||Pronunciation||Translation
 
|-
 
|-
| sign
+
| si'''gn'''
| si.gən
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/s/sign/recording1.mp3 [si.'''gən''']]
 
| 'sock, stocking'
 
| 'sock, stocking'
 
|-
 
|-
| tapu'gl
+
| tapu''''gl'''
| da.puː.gəl
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/t/tapu%27gl/recording1.mp3 [ta.puː.'''gəl''']]
 
| 'two of them'
 
| 'two of them'
 
|}
 
|}
  
If the two consonants are of equal sonority or identical, no schwa is inserted, as in the following examples:
+
† There is debate over whether there is actually a schwa inserted here, or if the sonorant is [[Syllables#Syllabic Sonorants|syllabic]]. For discussion, please see the page [[Stress]].
 +
 
 +
If the two consonants are of equal sonority or are identical, no schwa is inserted, as in the following examples:
  
 
{| class="wikitable"
 
{| class="wikitable"
|+
+
|+ No Schwa Insertion
 
! Word||Pronunciation||Translation
 
! Word||Pronunciation||Translation
 
|-
 
|-
| agnutg
+
| agnu'''tg'''
| a.gə.nutk
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/a/agnutg/recording1.mp3 [a.gə.nu'''tkʰ''']]
 
| 'he or she talks about it'
 
| 'he or she talks about it'
 
|-
 
|-
| sigu'sgw
+
| sigu''''sgw'''
| si.guːskʷ
+
| [http://www.mikmaqonline.org/words-mp3/media/s/sigu%27sgw/recording1.mp3 [si.guː'''skʷʰ''']]
 
| 'widow'
 
| 'widow'
 
|-
 
|-
| sgilminn
+
| sgilmi'''nn'''
| əs.gɪl.mɪnn
+
| [əs.gɪl.mɪ'''nn''']
 
| 'seeds'
 
| 'seeds'
 
|}
 
|}

Latest revision as of 15:45, 27 November 2012

In addition to the five main vowels a, e, i, o and u, Mi'gmaq has an additional "sixth vowel", or schwa. Written in the International Phonetic Alphabet, it is [ə]. When written in the Listuguj orthography, it is written with an apostrophe. However, regardless of the spelling system used, it is for the most part not written. This page describes the places where schwa is written and where it is not.

Where to Write Schwa

Schwa is written in any place where it is not predictable by rule. That is, it is written when it is said and not predicted by the writing system. The following section will detail the places where schwa is predictable and therefore not written.

Where NOT to Write Schwa

These are all the places where schwa is predictable and not included in the orthography. They are broken up by word-initial, word-medial, and word-final epenthesis or insertion rules. As a general rule of thumb, a schwa is inserted wherever a sequence of consonants cannot be syllabified in Mi'gmaq.

Word-Initial

The general rule for word-initial schwa epenthesis is as follows:

"When a word begins with two consonants, insert a schwa before the most sonorous consonant."

In this case, the "most sonorous" consonant is the consonant that is the loudest, or pronounced closest to the way a vowel is pronounced [1]. In Mi'gmaq, the hierarchy is as follows:

all vowels > l > n > m > s, p, t, g, q, gw, qw, and j

Some examples of where to insert schwa are given in the table below. Syllables are marked off with dots. All audio examples are taken from the Mi'gmaq Talking Dictionary.

Schwa before m, n, l
Word Pronunciation Translation
lnui'sit [əlː.nu.iː.sitʰ] 'he speaks the native language'
lmu'j [əl.muːtʃ] 'dog'
mlagejg [mə.la.gɛtʃkʰ] 'milk'
nmu'j [ən.muːtʃ] 'dog' (alternate pronunciation)
mntn [mənː.dən] 'mountain'
smtug [səm̩̊ː.tukʷʰ] 'right away'
slaps [sə.laps] 'slab of wood'
snawei [sə.na.wej] 'maple tree'

When the two consonants have the same sonority, however, the schwa is always placed before the first consonant. The following are some examples:

Schwa before Consonants of the Same Sonority
Word Pronunciation Translation
sgu'l [əsː.kuːl] 'school'
stoqon [əsː.tɔ.hon] 'fir tree'
lluigneg [əl.lu.i.gə.nɛkʰ] 'seven'
tgnu [ətʰ.kə.nu] 'sweat'
tqoq [ətʰ.ʕɔq͡χ] 'last fall'
ptaqan [əp.ta.ħan] 'plate'
tplutaqan [ət.pə.lu.da.ħan] 'law'
gsnqo'qon [ək.sənˑ.hoː.hwɔn] 'foolishness'

Word-Medial

When two consonants appear between two vowels within a word (and are not identical consonants, or a geminate consonant), the epenthesis rules are slightly different. Usually, the schwa appears between the consonants. However, this will only happen if the first consonant is lower in sonority than the second. In other words:

"When two non-identical consonants are between two vowels, insert a schwa only if the first consonant is less sonorous than the second. 
Otherwise, insert no schwa."

So, for example, a schwa will be inserted between q and n in the word oqnisgwa'tu, 'cover it up', so that it is pronounced [o.ħə.nis.gwaː.du]. However, no schwa is necessary between the s and the gw in this word since s is of the same sonority as gw. No schwa is needed in the word jiptug, 'perhaps', as well, since both consonants are of the same sonority.

Note, however, that the consonants l, m, and n count as the same sonority in this case - there is no schwa inserted between the m and the l in gamlamit, 'he or she breathes', because they count as the same.

When three or more consonants appear between two vowels (or word-initially), the schwa is generally inserted before the most sonorous, as in the word-initial cases listed above. Three examples are given below:

Schwa Insertion with Three Consonants
Word Pronunciation Translation
tplutaqan [ət.pə.lu.da.ħan] 'law'
o'plteg [oː.bəl.dɛkʰ] 'it's not set right'
gmsnmuaw [kəm.sən.mu.aw] 'do not take (imperative)'

In o'plteg, some speakers may simply replace the vowel with the l and pronounce it [oː.bl̩.dɛk]. This is very common word-finally, as in istua'latl, 'he or she turns him or her sideways', pronounced [isˑ.du.aː.la.tl̩].

For words that have many consonants in a row, it is best to pick out the most sonorous and insert a schwa before it. So, if a form like gsnqo'qon, 'foolishness', is encountered, a schwa will be inserted first before the n, giving the provisionary [ksən.qoː.qon]. No schwa needs to be inserted between the n and the q, since n is higher in sonority than q. A further schwa is needed to break up the gs, however, so by the word-initial rules, it is inserted before the g, giving the final [ək.sən.hoː.hwon].

If there is a double consonant or geminate, however, the schwa will appear after the geminate, as in ennmtesg, 'it pierces', pronounced [ɛn.nəm.tɛskʰ]. This is occasionally written with the apostrophe in the Listuguj orthography and occasionally not.

Word-Final

When two consonants are located at the end of a word, a schwa is only inserted if the second consonant is more sonorous than the first consonant.† Some examples are given below:

Word-Final Schwa Insertion
Word Pronunciation Translation
sign [si.gən] 'sock, stocking'
tapu'gl [ta.puː.gəl] 'two of them'

† There is debate over whether there is actually a schwa inserted here, or if the sonorant is syllabic. For discussion, please see the page Stress.

If the two consonants are of equal sonority or are identical, no schwa is inserted, as in the following examples:

No Schwa Insertion
Word Pronunciation Translation
agnutg [a.gə.nutkʰ] 'he or she talks about it'
sigu'sgw [si.guːskʷʰ] 'widow'
sgilminn [əs.gɪl.mɪnn] 'seeds'

References